Stephen Miller Lied About a Supreme Court Ruling, Now a Legally Protected Immigrant Is Trapped in a Foreign Prison
Stephen Miller lied about a Supreme Court ruling that ordered the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia. The Trump administration is defying the Court, and a constitutional crisis is unfolding.
In April 2025, the United States Supreme Court issued a unanimous ruling in Noem v. Abrego Garcia, ordering the government to facilitate the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Salvadoran man illegally deported despite a 2019 court order forbidding his removal. That order protected Garcia from deportation to El Salvador due to credible threats of persecution.
Instead of obeying the Court, the Trump administration left Garcia imprisoned in CECOT, a notorious Salvadoran facility known for human rights abuses.
Homeland Security called the deportation an “administrative error.” But as the days pass and Garcia remains behind bars, it’s clear: this was no error. This is deliberate defiance of a Supreme Court ruling.
We Are in a Constitutional Crisis
The Supreme Court clearly instructed the government to correct the unlawful deportation and provide Garcia with all due process he would’ve received had he remained in the U.S. Justice Sotomayor’s concurring opinion was unequivocal:
“The Government has cited no basis in law for [Garcia’s] warrantless arrest, his removal to El Salvador, or his confinement in a Salvadoran prison.”
Yet President Trump has admitted that he could call for Garcia’s return “in 30 minutes”, but simply refuses to.
This is a textbook constitutional crisis. Senator Chris Van Hollen has said so explicitly:
“We are in a constitutional crisis. The President is openly ignoring the law.”
The executive branch is refusing to comply with a ruling from the highest court in the country—and publicly admitting it. If left unchecked, this precedent dismantles the separation of powers and neutralizes the Supreme Court’s authority.
Kilmar Abrego Garcia Is Not the Criminal. Stephen Miller Is.
While Garcia, a father, husband, and longtime Maryland resident with no criminal record, remains locked in a foreign prison, the real architect of this crisis walks free: Trump advisor Stephen Miller.
Miller didn’t just participate in the deportation. He lied about the Supreme Court ruling, claiming it was a win for the administration. He denied Garcia had been mistakenly deported, despite official acknowledgments that it was illegal.
This wasn’t spin. It was obstruction, contempt, and conspiracy—on camera.
Four Legal Paths to Hold Stephen Miller Accountable
If justice matters, Stephen Miller must be investigated. Here’s how:
1. Criminal Contempt of Court
Miller may have knowingly encouraged defiance of a Supreme Court order, which is grounds for criminal contempt.
2. Obstruction of Justice (18 U.S.C. § 1505)
False public statements that hinder the enforcement of a federal court ruling could meet the standard for obstruction.
3. Conspiracy to Defraud the United States (18 U.S.C. § 371)
Coordinated disinformation from Miller and others to mislead the public and prevent court compliance may constitute conspiracy.
4. Misprision of Felony (18 U.S.C. § 4)
If Miller knew the deportation was unlawful and concealed it, he may be guilty of misprision.
Why This Should Terrify Every American
The Trump administration’s legal team argued that deportation eliminates a court’s power to intervene. In plain terms: they claimed the U.S. government can violate the law, deport someone, and leave them imprisoned in a foreign country, without consequence.
Justice Sotomayor warned exactly what this means:
“The Government’s argument implies that it could deport and incarcerate any person, including U.S. citizens, without legal consequence.”
That’s not law. That’s authoritarianism.
If We Don’t Act Now, There Will Be a Next Time
This isn’t theoretical. It’s happening. Right now. On American soil. Under the cover of executive authority.
A man legally protected by the courts was ripped from his home and dumped into a foreign prison.
Stephen Miller lied. The President defied the Court. And an innocent man is still trapped.
If we don’t hold them accountable, it won’t stop here.
#FreeKilmarGarcia
#HoldStephenMillerAccountable
#SCOTUSDefied
#ConstitutionalCrisis
